Malarkey vs IKO — Which Shingle Brand for BC?
Both are go to brands for Lower Mainland roofs, but they win on different things. IKO is the Canadian made value leader. Malarkey is the impact and resilience leader. Here is the brand level comparison to help you decide which fits your home. From Paragon Roofing BC, family owned since 2010.
Stepping back from individual shingles, IKO and Malarkey are two brands we install regularly and recommend often, but they sit in different places. IKO is Canadian made, which gives it a real edge on availability and price here, and its Dynasty line in particular is a strong shingle. Malarkey, made in Oregon, leads on impact resistance and resilient polymer technology. Here is how the brands compare overall so you can pick the right fit.
IKO: Canadian made value
IKO's biggest advantages are Canadian manufacturing, strong local availability, and sensible pricing. The IKO Dynasty is the standout, with a Class 3 impact rating, the ArmourZone reinforced nailing strip, a high wind rating up to 130 mph with four nails, Class A fire, and a Limited Lifetime warranty. The Cambridge sits below it as a popular value option. Across the range, IKO is the brand to beat on value for a Lower Mainland home, and the Dynasty punches well above its price.
Malarkey: impact and resilience
Malarkey's identity is durability. Their NEX polymer modified asphalt makes their shingles tougher and more flexible, and lines like the Vista carry a Class 4 impact rating, the highest available, along with 3M smog reducing granules and IBHS FORTIFIED construction. You pay more for Malarkey, but you get a shingle engineered for the harshest exposure. For storm prone, hail prone, or exposed homes, or homeowners who simply want the toughest roof, Malarkey is the brand.
Brand comparison
| Factor | IKO | Malarkey |
|---|---|---|
| Made in | Canada | Oregon, USA |
| Standout line | Dynasty (Class 3 impact) | Vista (Class 4 impact) |
| Signature tech | ArmourZone nailing strip | NEX polymer, 3M granules, FORTIFIED |
| Wind | Dynasty up to 130 mph, four nails | High, FORTIFIED built |
| Local availability | Excellent, Canadian made | Good |
| Relative cost | Lower, strong value | Higher, premium resilience |
| Best for | Value and local supply | Maximum durability and storms |
Which brand for your home
Both brands make roofs we are glad to stand behind with our 20 year workmanship warranty. Choose IKO for value and local supply, Malarkey for maximum durability. We install both with our own crew and will price each for your roof so you can decide. See our IKO and Malarkey product pages, or our asphalt shingle service.
Frequently Asked Questions
They win on different things. IKO is the value leader, Canadian made with excellent local availability and a strong Dynasty line. Malarkey is the durability leader, with Class 4 impact ratings and rubberized NEX polymer. Choose IKO for value and local supply, Malarkey for maximum resilience and storm exposure. Both make roofs we are happy to install and warranty.
IKO is Canadian made, which keeps availability high and pricing sensible in our market, and its lines are positioned as strong value. Malarkey is a premium, resilience focused brand built around tougher polymer technology and higher impact ratings, so you pay more for that engineering. Neither is cutting corners; they simply target different buyers.
Both perform well here when installed correctly. Malarkey has an edge in raw resilience thanks to its Class 4 impact rating and rubberized polymer, which suits exposed and storm prone homes. IKO Dynasty offers a high wind rating up to 130 mph with four nails and is plenty of shingle for most settings. Install quality matters more than the brand difference for typical homes.
Yes, we install both with our own in house crew, and we are an IKO Master Roofer. Carrying both lets us recommend based on your home, budget, and exposure rather than pushing one brand. We use a four nail pattern as standard on either.
The Dynasty is IKO's standout architectural shingle and punches above its price. It carries a Class 3 impact rating, the ArmourZone reinforced nailing strip, a wind rating up to 130 mph with four nails, Class A fire, and a Limited Lifetime warranty. It is a genuinely strong shingle that competes well above its cost bracket.
No. We provide the same 20 year workmanship warranty on the installation regardless of which brand you choose. The manufacturer product warranty varies by brand and line, but the workmanship coverage, which is what protects you against installation issues, stays the same.
IKO or Malarkey? Honest Advice and a Real Quote.
We install both brands with our own crew and price each for your roof so you can weigh value against durability. IKO Master Roofer certified. 20 year workmanship warranty.
Book Free Estimate IKO Products Call us any time: 604‑358‑343615+ years of Lower Mainland roofing experience. Harman leads project teams across Metro Vancouver and the Fraser Valley with a focus on institutional quality work for residential, strata, and commercial properties. Direct line: 604‑358‑3436.
Paragon Roofing BC
— Trusted Lower Mainland roofing contractor
IKO Products
· Malarkey Products
· Asphalt Shingles
· Shingle Materials
· Roof Replacement
· Contact
604‑358‑3436
· Book Inspection
We're Excited To Serve YOU!
Paragon Res Roof #1
We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Please try again later.
Here's What Our Existing Clients Think.
Home and business owners we've served across the greater Vancouver area.
Our Google Reviews
Edit Google Reviews Widget
Paragon Res Roof #3
We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Please try again later.
