Converting a Surrey Tar and Gravel Roof to Torch-On
Converting a Surrey Tar and Gravel Roof to Torch-On
Switching a Surrey tar and gravel roof to torch-on is a good move for most flat and low-slope buildings. The membrane you end up with is only as good as what happens before the first roll is lit: the deck check, the drainage check, the decision to strip or overlay, and the detail work at drains, edges and penetrations. Get those right and the wrinkles and fishmouths that show up on poorly installed torch-on roofs (we see the same questions come up from Burnaby owners) mostly never appear. This guide is for homeowners with flat sections, strata councils, property managers and commercial owners who plan to hire a roofer and want to know what a proper conversion involves.
TL;DR
- Tar and gravel (built-up roofing) is the older flat roof system. Torch-on is a modified bitumen membrane, usually two plies, welded down with a propane torch.
- Before converting, the roof needs a structural, deck, slope and drainage review. Removing gravel can reveal ponding that was hidden before.
- Whether to strip to the deck or overlay depends on what the inspection finds, not on a rule of thumb.
- Wrinkles and fishmouths usually trace back to wet or dirty substrates, poor torch technique or rushed lap work, and they are cut out and patched, not painted over.
- Torching is a fire-risk trade. Hire licensed, insured crews and keep combustibles away from the flame.
Table of Contents
Why Surrey owners are moving off tar and gravel
Tar and gravel roofs were the standard flat roof for decades across the Lower Mainland. Layers of felt and hot asphalt are topped with a gravel ballast that shields the surface from sun. They can last a long time, but the gravel makes them hard to inspect: a leak can run along the layers well away from where it enters, and moss and debris settle into the stones, especially under Surrey’s wet winters.
Torch-on sheds that problem. The surface is a granulated cap sheet you can see, walk and inspect, and seams are welded rather than mopped. The industry’s own description is a membrane of asphalt and polymer sheets melted together with a torch, which is why the quality of the work depends so heavily on the crew. For more on how the system goes down, see our torch-on installation process page and our flat roofing guide for Surrey.
What to assess before the conversion
The Canadian Roofing Contractors Association (CRCA) published a re-roofing advisory in June 2018 that lists what should be reviewed when one roof system replaces another. Four items matter most to a Surrey owner.
1. Structural loading
Changing systems can put different loads on the structure than the original design did. A roof that carried gravel ballast is not automatically carrying the same weight afterwards, and the new build-up may include added insulation or cover board. On older commercial buildings and strata podium decks, this is the first question to settle.
2. Deck condition
The advisory calls for assessing the deck surface and underside, with engineer review where there are signs of corrosion, spalling concrete or rot. A plywood or plank deck that has been wet under a failing membrane for years often needs sections replaced before anything is torched onto it. A deck that is sound today but damp is also a problem for the wrinkling reasons covered below.
3. Slope and drainage
This is where Surrey flat roofs surprise owners. The CRCA notes that replacing gravel with a lower-profile surface, such as a granule-surfaced or smooth membrane, can make previously hidden “bird bath” ponding more obvious. It defines ponding as water that stays 48 to 72 hours under conditions that should dry it. Gravel hides shallow low spots. A new membrane shows them.
That is not a reason to avoid torch-on. It is a reason to check the drains, the slope and the low spots before pricing, so the new roof is designed to shed water. Blocked or undersized drains are common on flat roofs here, and a conversion is the cheapest moment to fix them.
4. Hazardous materials
Older roofing and flashing materials can contain asbestos. The CRCA lists hazardous material assessment as part of the review, and on an older building it should happen before demolition starts, not during it.
Overlay or full tear-off?
Owners often ask whether torch-on can go straight over the old tar and gravel. The honest answer is that it depends on the inspection. A Lower Mainland roofing guide frames it the same way: the deck, insulation and drainage are inspected first, and then the decision is made between removal down to the deck or an overlay.
Some points help you read that decision:
- Wet insulation or a soft deck points to a full tear-off. Trapped moisture under a new membrane is a long-term problem, and a sound-looking top surface can hide it.
- Exposed organic felts are a fire concern. IKO’s specification says heat-fusing a patch to exposed organic felts or other combustibles is not recommended. This is one reason gravel and old felts have to be dealt with carefully before any flame is used.
- Gravel must be dealt with either way. Loose stone under a torch-applied sheet leaves a lumpy, poorly adhered surface.
- Drainage corrections usually need access to the deck or insulation. If the roof ponds, a tear-off lets the slope be built in, for example with tapered insulation.
On a Surrey townhouse complex or a commercial building with rooftop equipment, we would want to walk the roof, open a few test cuts and look at the deck before telling a council or owner which route makes sense. Our commercial roofing services and strata and multifamily roofing services pages cover how we approach these projects.
How a proper torch-on conversion goes down
The details below come from manufacturer and trade-association documents. They are what a well-run crew works to, and what a council or property manager can read in a scope of work.
Substrate and base sheet
Garland’s application guide says the surface must not be contaminated with dust, dirt, oil or moisture. Approved roof board is primed and left to dry completely before torching. Torching over wet primer can cause a flash fire, so the primer has to be tack-free first.
The same guide has the base sheet relaxed until it lies flat, laid in lengths of no more than 18 ft (5.5 m), with side laps of the cap sheet offset 18 in (457 mm) from the base sheet laps. A continuous molten bitumen bleed-out of 3 to 10 mm should show at every seam, and the base sheet is swept before the cap goes on.
ARCA’s October 2025 manual also limits where torch-adhered base sheets can go. They are permitted on concrete, glass-faced gypsum cover board, gypsum fibre cover board and asphalt core board, where approved by ARCA Warranty Ltd. and the membrane manufacturer. Base sheet side laps are a minimum of 64 mm (2.5 in) and end laps 150 mm (6 in), staggered at least 300 mm (12 in) from adjacent laps.
Cap sheet and laps
The CRCA Reference Manual gives minimum side laps of 75 mm (3 in) and end laps of 150 mm (6 in) for the membrane. It calls for a 34 kg (75 lb) segmented steel roller to press the rolls and eliminate voids. It also requires misaligned rolls to be cut off and reset.
Drains, edges, parapets and penetrations
Most leaks on converted roofs start at details, not in the field of the membrane. ARCA’s February 2024 manual sets out the following for cast internal drains:
- The hopper flange is primed and set about 19 mm (3/4 in) below the membrane surface, in a sump of roughly 1000 × 1000 mm.
- Lead flashing extends 150 mm (6 in) beyond the hopper flange.
- A polyester-reinforced SBS base flashing ply goes on at 45° to the base sheet laps.
- The cap sheet covers the flashing, with laps at least 300 mm (12 in) from the bowl edge.
- A clamping ring and dome are tightened down.
The same ARCA manual requires membrane flashing at all terminations to be installed as the work progresses, so the roof is watertight at the end of every day. Flashing must be supported by at least 12.7 mm (1/2 in) plywood, dimensional lumber, smooth concrete or masonry, or 22-gauge flat sheet metal. At the perimeter, the October 2025 manual calls for base sheets to turn up vertical surfaces at least 75 mm (3 in), anchored with a steel bar, primed plywood or approved fastening plates at 300 mm centres.
On a Surrey strip mall, that means every HVAC curb, vent and parapet is a flashing job in its own right. On a strata building it means roof drains and scuppers deserve as much scope-of-work attention as the field area.
Wrinkles and fishmouths in new torch-on roofs
Burnaby and Surrey owners ask about these because they show up in the first months after installation and look alarming. Here is what causes them and what a correct response looks like.
What causes wrinkles
- Moisture in the substrate. Soprema’s Canadian roofer’s guide notes that on wood decks, wrinkles or delamination can appear at board junctions, usually soon after installation when moisture in the boards evaporates. After a Surrey fall or winter, decks are rarely bone dry, so deck moisture is something the crew has to manage.
- A base sheet that was not relaxed. Rolls laid before they lie flat tend to buckle later.
- Technique. The CRCA Reference Manual says continuous torch movement, continuous unrolling and proper rolling improve adhesion and minimize wrinkles and blisters.
What causes fishmouths
A fishmouth is an open, curled edge or lap. Soprema’s guide says fishmouths and wrinkles can be caused by pointing the flame between the two layers with the torch head inverted, which traps air. Poor lap bleed-out and unrolled edges add to the problem.
When a wrinkle is a defect
Not every ripple needs action, but significant ones do. IKO’s specification says any unsealed significant wrinkle and all fishmouth areas must be cut and repaired so the membrane lies flat without leaving a hump or void. Base sheet repair sections extend at least 150 mm (6 in) past the deficiency in each direction, and the cap sheet patch goes a further 50 mm (2 in) beyond the base patch. The CRCA says fishmouths, wrinkles and buckles found during installation should be cut out and patched.
What a correct repair looks like
The CRCA’s repair procedure for built-up membranes has these steps, and they are a useful benchmark for any repair scope:
- Expose the area and prepare the surface, spudding gravel free and sweeping it clean on gravel roofs.
- Cut the fishmouth, wrinkle or ridge with a sharp utility knife.
- Inspect for leakage and remove any wet or damaged insulation.
- Cut the defect back to an adhered area and prime with asphalt primer.
- Complete the repair with at least two plies: the bottom ply at least 150 mm (6 in) beyond the repair area and each following ply 75 mm (3 in) beyond the one below.
The CRCA procedure also sets the preparation area at a minimum of 450 mm (18 in) beyond the defect’s perimeter. A surface coat of sealant over a fishmouth does not meet this standard. If a repair is quoted that way, it is a cosmetic fix.
Fire safety when torching
Torch-on is a hot-work trade. Flame temperatures can exceed 1093°C (2000°F), according to the CRCA Reference Manual, and couplings and cylinders must be tested and tight.
Soprema’s guide states that heat-welded membranes must never be installed directly on wood or near combustible products. Non-combustible cover panels and flame shields keep the flame off wooden substrates. That matters on older Surrey buildings with wood parapets, wood-framed curbs or combustible insulation at the edges.
For owners and strata councils, the practical points are simple. Use a licensed, insured roofing contractor. Make sure the scope names how wood edges and penetrations will be protected. Tell the building’s insurer about hot work if the policy asks. For a strata corporation, record all this in the council’s minutes along with the contract.
Planning the project as an owner or council
- Start with an inspection, not a quote. Decisions about overlay versus tear-off, deck repair and drainage come from what is found on the roof.
- Ask for the scope in writing. It should name the substrate prep, base and cap plies, drain details, perimeter turn-ups and flashing at each penetration.
- Plan around weather. Priming and substrate dryness are weather-sensitive, so Surrey’s wet season affects scheduling. Many owners book their conversions for the drier months.
- Allow for drainage work. If ponding was hidden by gravel, budgeting for added drains or tapered insulation avoids surprises.
- Look at permits with the city. Structural changes, new rooftop equipment or roof shape changes can trigger permit requirements. Check with the City of Surrey before work begins.
Promo
Paragon Roofing BC handles residential, commercial and strata roof installation, repairs and maintenance, as well as removal and reroofing, in Surrey, Burnaby, Delta, Coquitlam, North Vancouver and West Vancouver. If you are weighing a tar and gravel conversion, start with our Surrey commercial roof installation page or get in touch through our main site and we will arrange an inspection of the roof.
For homes with flat sections, our residential roofing services cover installation, repairs, maintenance and inspections. Emergency roof repairs are also on offer if a leak cannot wait.
Perspective
Most flat roof problems we are asked about in Surrey and Burnaby are not about the membrane. They are about what sat underneath it or around it: a damp deck, a drain that never had enough slope, a curb flashed in a hurry.
That is why we focus on city-specific roofing problems rather than a one-size-fits-all approach. A tar and gravel roof in Surrey has its own history of water, moss and patch repairs, and the conversion should respond to that history. Torch-on is a strong system for these roofs because it is visible, repairable and welded rather than mopped. It rewards careful prep and careful detailing.
Our team is licensed and insured, and we would rather spend an hour on the roof before quoting than guess from the street. If you own, manage or sit on the council of a building with a worn gravel roof, that inspection is where a good conversion starts.
Harman
FAQ
Can torch-on go over an existing tar and gravel roof?
Sometimes, but only after the deck, insulation and drainage have been inspected. Wet insulation, a soft deck or ponding usually point to removal down to the deck. The gravel and any loose material have to be dealt with either way.
Why do wrinkles appear in a new torch-on roof?
Moisture in the deck or board substrate is a common cause, along with a base sheet that was not relaxed flat before it was bonded. Soprema notes wrinkles can appear at wood board junctions soon after installation as moisture evaporates. Significant unsealed wrinkles should be cut and patched.
What is a fishmouth and does it need repair?
It is an open or curled edge in a lap that can let water in. Industry specifications call for fishmouths to be cut and repaired so the membrane lies flat, with patches extending at least 150 mm (6 in) beyond the defect.
Will my flat roof pond after the gravel comes off?
It can. The CRCA notes that replacing gravel with a lower-profile surface can make bird-bath ponding more visible. A slope and drainage check before the conversion lets any low spots be corrected as part of the job.
Sources
- CRCA Advisory: Re-roofing design considerations (June 2018)
- Garland StressPly IV Plus torch-applied two-ply application guide
- ARCA MB Manual, October 21, 2025
- ARCA MB Manual, February 2024
- Soprema Roofer’s Guide: Bituminous Membranes
- IKO Part 15: Post-Job, Sheet Metal and Miscellaneous Requirements
- CRCA Reference Manual 5.2.2: Application of Membrane
- CRCA Reference Manual 13.2.1: Built-up Roofs (BUR) Membranes
Recommended
Our Roofing Blog
Have more questions about roofing?
Check out our FAQs or give us a call today to speak to an expert roofer in Vancouver Lower Mainland, BC. We're here to help our neighbours make educated decisions about their roof. For our team, we value helping clients save money while making their roofs last.




